1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Spanish Language

Keep Auxiliary and Main Verbs Together

Separating Verbs Common in English, Not Spanish

By Gerald Erichsen, About.com

In general, it is not grammatically proper in Spanish to place words between the auxiliary verb haber or estar and the verb it is associated with. Such a practice is common in English but should not be duplicated in Spanish.

For example, it is acceptable in English to use sentences such as "I have not seen it" or "he has often said false things." (The auxiliary and main verbs are shown in boldface.) But that word order cannot be normally be used in Spanish. These sentences must be expressed in Spanish as "no lo he visto" and "muchas veces ha dicho cosas equivocadas."

It is sometimes awkward in English to insert an adverb or other word between forms of "to be" and the gerund (the "-ing" form of the verb), but it is still done frequently. For example, "China is rapidly growing." But again, that word order normally isn't used in Spanish: "China está creciendo rápido."

Other than in works that have been poorly translated into Spanish, there are two instances where you're likely to see auxiliary and main verbs separated:

  • Sometimes, a word or phrase can be inserted between a form of haber and a past participle to provide the sentence with a literary flavor. Example: No obstante, esta Corte ha, otra vez, rehusado a acogerse a esta propuesta. (Nevertheless, this court has, again, refused to invoke this proposal.)
  • Pronouns can be attached to haber or habiendo. Example: Muchas personas dijeron haberlo visto vivo. (Many people reported having seen him alive.)
Seguir, when used an auxiliary verb, also generally isn't separated from the main verb: Siguen luchando duramente contra el gobierno. (The keep on fighting hard against the government.)
More Spanish Language Quick Tips

Explore Spanish Language

More from About.com

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Spanish Language
  4. Learn Spanish Grammar
  5. Parts of Speech
  6. Verbs
  7. Separation of Auxiliary and Main Verbs - Learn Spanish Language

©2008 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.