Spanish Language

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Spanish Language
photo of Gerald Erichsen

Gerald's Spanish Language Blog

By Gerald Erichsen, About.com Guide to Spanish Language since 1998

Racist comment? Read the original Spanish, decide for yourself

Monday May 16, 2005
Did Mexican President Vicente Fox display a streak of racism Friday when he said that Mexicans in the United States are doing jobs that "that not even blacks want to do"? Or were his comments misinterpreted? The question certainly is being debated by the pundits and some civil rights leaders in the United States, who have asked for (and been refused) an apology.
 
But one thing is certain: Fox's comments aren't the subject of a political fury because they were mistranslated. By and large, his comments have been translated correctly by the American media. For the record, here's what Fox had to say at a conference in Puerto Vallarta, Mexico, last Friday:
    No hay duda que los mexicanos y las mexicanas, llenos de dignidad, de voluntad y de capacidad de trabajo, están haciendo trabajos que ni siquiera los negros quieren hacer allá, en Estados Unidos.
One possible translation: "There is no doubt that Mexicans, full of dignity, determination and the ability to work, are taking jobs that not even the blacks want to do there, in the United States." It should be noted that the phrase ni siquiera, usually translated "not even," is an emphatic usage (a less emphatic ni could have been used instead), although it is impossible to determine how emphatic without hearing the words spoken.
 
In other words, whatever ambiguity and/or insensitivity there is in Fox's remarks is present in his original words no more and no less than the translations of his words that have been widely reported.

Comments

No comments yet. Leave a Comment

Leave a Comment

Line and paragraph breaks are automatic. Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title="">, <b>, <i>, <strike>

Discuss

Community Forum

Explore Spanish Language

About.com Special Features

How to Ace the GRE

Being well prepared is the first step; here are more essential suggestions. More >

The Business School Lowdown

Everything from choosing a school and applying, to employment after graduation. More >

Spanish Language

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Spanish Language

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.